Why do we say, ‘tuna fish’ but not ‘beef mammal’ or ‘chicken bird’?

r/

Why do we say, ‘tuna fish’ but not ‘beef mammal’ or ‘chicken bird’?

Comments

  1. BedraggledCat Avatar

    That is a fantastic question. Only thing I can guess is that it’s to distinguish the canned stuff from tuna steak. You have a tuna fish sandwich, but if you’re getting nice stuff at a restaurant, it’s just tuna (or ahi).

    Edit: But I am 100% going to start saying beef mammal and chicken bird.

  2. Chemical_Path4533 Avatar

    Australians call it tuna. Tuna sandwich, tuna on crackers tuna with spiders eggs, tuna wrap. Maybe it’s just an American thing.

  3. NewRelm Avatar

    I always assumed it was to distinguish it from the tuna fruit, also known as prickly pear.

  4. imagicnation-station Avatar

    Because you can tune a piano, but you can’t tuna fish.

    It may be the case where some of the earlier cans were labeled “tuna fish”, and just like how brand names when they become popular are used as the name for the product itself (like the word qtip), perhaps “tuna fish” became the same way.

  5. Sad_Evidence5318 Avatar

    I just call it tuna

  6. Alh84001-1984 Avatar

    Because in this context, “fish” is not used to talk about the animal, but about the food. “Fish” is not just a biology word to refer to a type of aquatic animal, it is also a culinary term referring to the consumable flesh of these animals. Thus, in that sense and in that context, “fish” is analogous to “beef”, not to “cow”. We say “tuna fish” to specify the kind of fish, exactly like we also say “wagyu beef”, “beluga caviar” or “duck fat”. At this point, it’s an ingredient and no longer an animal.

  7. SoapyUtahpops Avatar

    Who’s this “we” I never hear anyone say that.. it’s just tuna.

  8. MushyBeans Avatar

    English here, we just say ‘Tuna’ and ‘Beef curtains’

  9. Canuck647 Avatar

    We call it tuna.

  10. Cautious-Natural-512 Avatar

    Because america?
    I dont know if anyone else really does this

  11. Under_Lock_An_Key Avatar

    It was a marketing gimmick.

    They wanted to emphasize that it was from the sea. Can you believe it, folks! In a can! TUNA FISH.

    If you get the actual fish, they just call it Tuna!

  12. Krapmeister Avatar

    We don’t, Americans do (once they’ve finished horseback riding).

  13. NzRedditor762 Avatar

    Tuna fish is weird to me. Tuna.

  14. Khorvair Avatar

    people call it tuna fish?

  15. whereismydragon Avatar

    ‘We’ don’t. It’s yet another weird American thing.

  16. morhp Avatar

    Might come from people with a German background.

    In the German language we say Thunfisch for tuna fish and Haifisch for shark. The added Fisch/fish is likely because the words “T(h)un” and “H(a)i” are very common words in the language and without the fish context they could be very confusing.

    E.g. “Möchtest du was t(h)un?” would be understand as “Do you want to do something?” and not as “Do you want some tuna?”.

  17. Better-Drag8322 Avatar

    In India, i heard they called tengna 😂

  18. Bastdkat Avatar

    I am American, NO ONE I know calls it tuna fish, it is tuna.

  19. Manzilla48 Avatar

    Only Americans feel the need to confirm they’re talking about fish when they use the word tuna.

  20. 0thell0perrell0 Avatar

    Could be that tuna in Spanish is the fruit of the cactus

  21. Kittens4Brunch Avatar

    No one I know says tuna fish.

  22. SchoolForSedition Avatar

    Older English here. Yes, I remember it would be called tuna fish. Perhaps we weren’t then expected to know immediately what tuna was.

  23. Blarghnog Avatar

    I’m going tomorrow for sword, sun and blob. 

    Later I’m going to Japan for some sea chicken. And then Finland for tonnikala. And then off to Norway for some tonfisk.

  24. Novae224 Avatar

    I never say tuna fish

  25. Disastrous-Capybara Avatar

    I dont know, but in german its also called Thunfisch 😁

  26. Kentwomagnod Avatar

    American but I call it ahi or maguro or maybe skipjack

  27. katya_luzon Avatar

    saying “tuna fish” seems like an american thing. it also happens with eye glasses and horseback riding. in australia we drop all of the extra words