AITA for complimenting a guy with a wife

r/

I (16F) have had extremely bad social anxiety my entire life. So bad that until the end of middle school I was basically mute in public. The therapist i’m working with abt this suggested I try complimenting someone. After this, when I was at the store I saw someone with an XO Weeknd hoodie, I was genuinely curious where he got it from. For context, this is a grown man with a wife and a toddler. I didn’t think this would be wrong since I’m VERY CLEARLY a teenager. I walk up to him and say, “where did you get that hoodie from? I love the Weeknd” and the guy replies, in the rudest tone he possibly can, “online” then his wife looked me up and down and said “that compliment wasn’t necessary” and that was the end of the interaction. It prob doesn’t seem like a big deal to most but this was a huge step for me. Some ppl I told abt this are siding with me but others think i’m in the wrong since I had a crop top on (with baggy jeans, nothing extremely revealing) while complimenting a guy with a gf

Comments

  1. AutoModerator Avatar

    ^^^^AUTOMOD Thanks for posting! This comment is a copy of your post so readers can see the original text if your post is edited or removed. This comment is NOT accusing you of copying anything. Read this before contacting the mod team

    I (16F) have had extremely bad social anxiety my entire life. So bad that until the end of middle school I was basically mute in public. The therapist i’m working with abt this suggested I try complimenting someone. After this, when I was at the store I saw someone with an XO Weeknd hoodie, I was genuinely curious where he got it from. For context, this is a grown man with a wife and a toddler. I didn’t think this would be wrong since I’m VERY CLEARLY a teenager. I walk up to him and say, “where did you get that hoodie from? I love the Weeknd” and the guy replies, in the rudest tone he possibly can, “online” then his wife looked me up and down and said “that compliment wasn’t necessary” and that was the end of the interaction. It prob doesn’t seem like a big deal to most but this was a huge step for me. Some ppl I told abt this are siding with me but others think i’m in the wrong since I had a crop top on (with baggy jeans, nothing extremely revealing) while complimenting a guy with a gf

    I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

  2. Judgement_Bot_AITA Avatar

    Welcome to /r/AmITheAsshole. Please view our voting guide here, and remember to use only one judgement in your comment.

    OP has offered the following explanation for why they think they might be the asshole:

    > I think that people judged me for it since I walked up to a guy with a gf and complimented him while wearing a crop top

    Help keep the sub engaging!

    Don’t downvote assholes!

    Do upvote interesting posts!

    Click Here For Our Rules and Click Here For Our FAQ

    Subreddit Announcements

    Follow the link above to learn more

    Check out our holiday break announcement here!


    I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

    Contest mode is 1.5 hours long on this post.

  3. binger5 Avatar

    NTA

    That dude definitely cheated on his wife before.

  4. Then_Penalty_460 Avatar

    NTA. That’s a bizarre reaction to receiving a benign compliment and I hope you realize their reactions had nothing to do with you. Most sane adults would be happy a teenager thought their clothes were cool. 

  5. Realistic_Head4279 Avatar

    NTA. Clearly nothing wrong with your comment and question. Some people are just not very nice or social so maybe you just picked the wrong person to approach. Don’t take it too personally.

  6. Snurgisdr Avatar

    NTA. That is completely appropriate. They were just rude.

  7. loveanythingimyinbox Avatar

    NTA. People can be assholes. No matter what, if you were not rude, the attitude was unfounded.
    Please remember though, you have no idea what kind of day / week they were having, don’t take it personally.

    If someone says something off to me, here’s my thought process… 1:Have I insulted this person, 2:have I been rude.
    If the answer is no, then generally it’s a them not a you issue.
    Keep at it !

  8. Chemical_Shirt7837 Avatar

    Nta just super bad luck. Try again I’m sure you’ll go fine

  9. Few_Recover_6622 Avatar

    NTA. How rude of them.

    That was not about you, I bet they have issues with cheating.

  10. SalaudChaud Avatar

    Their response says a lot about them and nothing about you. NTA

  11. madelynashton Avatar

    NTA. They have their own issues. There’s nothing wrong with what you said, or your crop top. Crop tops are super popular.

  12. Martin_Antell Avatar

    NTA, don’t let it get you down. They were probably having some marital issues, not your fault.

  13. RJG-340 Avatar

    Man why are adults such dicks!!! It was very basic question, as for me I’d be expecting a very basic answer, do you live in Connecticut it kinda sounds like some of the people around where I live :(((

  14. RJG-340 Avatar

    Man why are adults such dicks!!! It was very basic question, as for me I’d be expecting a very basic answer, do you live in Connecticut it kinda sounds like some of the people around where I live :(((

  15. That-expanse-606 Avatar

    NTA- Where did you compliment him? I love the weekend is not complimenting anything to HIM

  16. FiberIsLife Avatar

    NTA. At ALL.

    That response had NOTHING to do with you, and a whole bunch to do with whatever shit was rolling around inside someone else’s relationship.

    You keep on complimenting people. You can bring little bits of happy into people’s lives, and that is the very best superpower.

  17. Prymas_tv Avatar

    NTA. Listen, if there’s one thing I’ve learned in 30 years is most people are jerks. If you keep your expectations low then you can’t be offended. The nice thing about low expectations of people is that when you find someone who is genuine, you end up becoming friends pretty quick

  18. ChibiSailorMercury Avatar

    Then, guys on Reddit: Why don’t women compliment more?

    (because it is generally perceived as advances and we’re not troubling our peace over the aftermath and having to deal with jealous SOs, awkward rejection for worse)

    NTA. Stick to complimenting women only.

  19. EmceeSuzy Avatar

    NTA but the next time you try this exercise, give a compliment to a peer to a young woman your age.

  20. KrisKrossKringe Avatar

    NTA… Some girls are just mean

  21. ExoQube Avatar

    Congrats on beginning to take steps to break out of your shell and I hope this negative experience doesn’t deter you in the future. This might be a regional thing, I’ve been to places with super friendly people that’d love the opportunity for a conversation. I live somewhere that has ruder people like this. I’m going to assume because you have social anxiety your tone and mannerisms probably came across as.. off. There’s nothing wrong with that, but that also could be why you got a rude response.

    All of that to say you’re NTA but probably pick your audience better. Even in my rude area woman to woman compliments always seem to go over well. Even if it’s a single dude, he may fall in love with you from one compliment. And I know the dudes will downvote me for that, but it’s just riskier complimenting men in general. Especially when you’re beginning to branch out of your social anxiety. Feel free to do so when you’ve gained a better feel for people

  22. Holiday-Judgment-136 Avatar

    If the wife has a issue with a 16 year old girl complimenting her husband, the issue is with her, not you.

  23. Afraid-Combination15 Avatar

    NTA, that wasn’t anything crazy or inappropriate or offensive. It was rather a nice thing to do, and keep being nice to fellow humans.

    People are just super unsociable sometimes. It’s gotten soooooo much worse in the last decade. It’s like we want to live in society, but more and more, don’t want to partake in it.

  24. Abject-Lengthiness42 Avatar

    So confusing 😕

    I wouldn’t think this is an odd thing to say! You weren’t even complimenting particularly, just asking a question…

    Hope this hasn’t knocked your confidence.

  25. Stormy_Spirit Avatar

    Holy fuck, NTA at all. Weird jealous people have actual problems. That’s completely on them, not you. It doesn’t matter what you were wearing at all. Please don’t let it get to you, I love complimenting people, and I love when people compliment my boyfriend. For them to think a 16 year old is competition is extra fucked. They are the problem, not you, not at all.

  26. Deviant-Killer Avatar

    You complimented the weeknd to a random guy and asked where you could get a hoodie…

    You didn’t compliment him.

  27. blarryg Avatar

    Read Albert Ellis “A Guide to Rational Living.” It’s a big deal to you, but you have to realize: You have social anxiety (back in my day, I was just “shy”). (Excess) anxiety is the most treatable form of mental illness (what you have is dysfunctional and highly limiting to what you can do in life). The treatment is graded exposure under physiological relaxation.

    So, congrats on making one interaction that happened to be with people who are either assholes or misunderstood. You need to do 1000 interactions, one per day until it’s 5-10 per day until it feels about as anxious as brushing your teeth. I did this to overcome shyness, now I give talks on networking, how to make friends etc. I used to get nervous about public speaking, so I relaxed and gave 100s of talks. Now I get about as nervous giving a talk as petting my cat (I’ve been scratched by both).

    You’re dwelling too much, some people are mean, others kind, most are just more involved with their own thoughts than with judging or thinking about you. Find all types. You have to find the mean ones because 100 of those will help you get over it as no big deal. Good luck.