My favorite ice cream flavor is mint chocolate chip. I love the refreshing taste of mint combined with the crunch of chocolate—it’s the perfect balance!
Chocolate and strawberry. I like them more when they’re mixed. My wife says it’s a weird flavor combination. We went and got cold stone today and the woman mixing the flavors agreed with her. No one bats an eye at chocolate covered strawberries though.
anyone else wonder why everyones dads favorite flavor is “breyers mint chip” and yes it has to be white because it “tastes better than the green” ??? i know like 3 dads like this. including my own
Milk and cookies but specifically from a creamery near me. They actually operate it on a farm and process it on site. Don’t know what they do to it but it’s my absolute favorite.
Edit: typo.
Pistachio Almond, Praline Pecan, strawberry vanilla, which sometimes I make at home for me and the kids. It can be a lot of work but well worth it because of all the simple ingredients instead of artificial colors, preservatives and high fructose corn syrup found in commercial ice cream.
My local ice cream shop has a flavor called elephant tracks – chocolate ice cream with fudge swirl and peanut butter cup chunks. It’s amazing. Mint Chocolate Chip is a close second, though.
This might sound odd, but I used to love an ice cream called After Dinner Mint. It was white with green and chocolate mint chips—so good. I think it was made by Thrifty. I don’t remember the exact price, but I believe you could get a cone for around 39 cents. This was in the 80s/90s! Not sure about a favorite flavor but I love Milk Brand and Handels Ice Cream now!
Pretty torn between vanilla and cotton candy.
What I like to do with vanilla is put some peanut butter in a microwavable dish and melt it runny. Pour it over the cold ice cream, and it’ll harden a bit into this really fudgy coating. I know you can buy peanut butter topping, but the texture is totally different using actual peanut butter. It’s creamier and smoother.
Three Twins (no longer in business, sadly) used to have a flavor called Dad’s Cardamon. I had never knowingly tasted cardamom before so this was a very interesting flavor.
Comments
cookie dough
Mint
Choco, what else
Watermelon sherbet for the real ones
raspberry chocolate chip
Ben & Jerry phish food
Cookies and Cream
Pistachio
My favorite ice cream flavor is mint chocolate chip. I love the refreshing taste of mint combined with the crunch of chocolate—it’s the perfect balance!
Chocolate and strawberry. I like them more when they’re mixed. My wife says it’s a weird flavor combination. We went and got cold stone today and the woman mixing the flavors agreed with her. No one bats an eye at chocolate covered strawberries though.
Pistachio gelato is the best ever
Cookie Dough 🩷
Lavender. Underrated.
Wild berries
Hagaan Daz’s Dulce De Leche, B&R’s Gold Medal and Jamocha Almond Fudge, B&J’s Cookie Dough
Chocolate peanut butter!!!!
Cotton candy
Mint chocolate chip
Great choice!
mint chocolate chip the natural made one without added sugar or artificial food coloring 😭
if I’m gonna have to be basic it’d be vanilla lmao others mint chocolate chip or cookies & cream are my go to.
Vanilla
chocolate/vanilla twist with rainbow sprinkles
Butter pecan
Mmmmm, praline and pecan.
anyone else wonder why everyones dads favorite flavor is “breyers mint chip” and yes it has to be white because it “tastes better than the green” ??? i know like 3 dads like this. including my own
It’s a toss up, cookies and cream and pecan preline are strong. I make my own and avacado is an interesting one
Mint chocolate chip 😘
It’s a triple threat: Real Pistachio (not the artificial stuff w/almonds), Green Tea, & Chocolate Blackout
r/casualconversation …
Vanilla 100%
Peppermint stick
Chocolate peanut butter cup
Mint choc chip for I old and this was posh when I was young
Moose tracks 🫎
Rum raisin!
Milk and cookies but specifically from a creamery near me. They actually operate it on a farm and process it on site. Don’t know what they do to it but it’s my absolute favorite.
Edit: typo.
Pure vanilla! True vanilla!
I’ve never tried it, I’m curious now.
Strawberry/Oreo
Graeter’s Black Raspberry Chip is the best
Moonbeam Icecream
Messina’s Super Dulce de Leche.
Or Maggie Beer’s burnt fig, honeycomb and caramel.
Or Wendy’s choc mint (with the chewy brownie bits, oh damn).
Coffee Crumble
cookies & cream na hershey
Blue Moon.
Fudge ripple
Chocolate
Chocolate chip
Love lemon chiffon but hardly see it anymore..which is probably a good thing in my case 😆
Baskin Robbins coffee ice cream
Graeter’s black raspberry chocolate chip. It’s a Cincinnati thing. IYKYK
I remembered Biden’s chocolate chocolate chip meme
Salted Caramel OMG
vanlliaaaa w literally anything (cereal my fav)
I dunno
Vanilla Fudge aka Fudge Awirl. No thank you rocky road
Mackinac Island Fudge
Banana Split! Best Blue Belle ever.
SELECTA,THE best Seller flavor
Double DUTCH
mint chocolate chip
Chocolate chip
Burgundy cherry
Pistachio Almond, Praline Pecan, strawberry vanilla, which sometimes I make at home for me and the kids. It can be a lot of work but well worth it because of all the simple ingredients instead of artificial colors, preservatives and high fructose corn syrup found in commercial ice cream.
Hudsonville Traverse City Cherry Fudge.
I would eat it every day if I could.
Ube
Peppermint stick.
Cookie dough from Halo Top.
Edy’s French Vanilla
Heavenly Hash
It changes every week but mango and chocolate mixed is good.
Chocolate chip mint!! OR Tillamook Marion berry pie woof def ate a gallon of that in one sitting before
Bananas Foster. Not easy to find!!
Hokey Pokey
My local ice cream shop has a flavor called elephant tracks – chocolate ice cream with fudge swirl and peanut butter cup chunks. It’s amazing. Mint Chocolate Chip is a close second, though.
Rocky road
Vanilla
I’m basic
Good ol’ fashion chocolate!!
cookies & cream is the only correct answer
Chocolate peanut butter mix
Vanilla, so simple but yet so perfect.
Chocolate, Cookies & Cream, Cookie Dough, or Espresso Flake
I’m gonna be an old lady and say Spumoni. Similar to Neapolitan but instead of choc,straw,vanilla it’s choc,pistachio,cherry
No one saying banana split or zabaglione? U guys don’t have this in the US?
Mint chip. (Green)
Yes.
But seriously though, it’s a toss-up of dulce de leche, matcha, strawberry, boysenberry and maybe a couple of other flavours.
Depends on the brand. Blue Bell chocolate and Blue Ribbon cookies and cream
Butter pecan 😋
Peanut butter and chocolate always.
Chocolate chip cookie dough
Pralines and dick
I had Baileys ice cream once, pretty awesome.
Rocky road
chocolate chip cookie dough
Elbow
Double chocolate Klondike, and it bloody vanished from everywhere:((
Plain vanilla is good enough for me
Mint chocolate chip is one of them, but I think my all-time favorite is cherry vanilla. Blue Bell has a very well-made one.
Cherry Garcia
Black Cherry Chocolate Chunk
Moose chunks
Cold brew gelato! It’s amazing
Tiger-tiger
100% mint chocolate chip. Too bad I can’t eat much ice cream bc it hurts my teeth like crazy.
Anything gelato
Vanilla
Chocolate
Coffee
Salted Caramel
Tiramisu. When I was a kid, I became overweight by eating it every day.
Of the ones I like I don’t favor one more than another
Vanilla, and also chocomint.
This might sound odd, but I used to love an ice cream called After Dinner Mint. It was white with green and chocolate mint chips—so good. I think it was made by Thrifty. I don’t remember the exact price, but I believe you could get a cone for around 39 cents. This was in the 80s/90s! Not sure about a favorite flavor but I love Milk Brand and Handels Ice Cream now!
Anything that tastes natural and mild. Not a fan of fake flavour. Nothing beats a good natural vanilla ice cream or a good berry ice cream
No, you are elegant!
Salted caramel pretzel
Interesting combination…
Raspberry heath mocha.
First had it at cold stone creamery years ago—fresh raspberries, chopped heath bar in mocha ice cream.
Insanely addictive.
Vanilla with peanut butter chunks in it 😋
Cookies n cream.
Coffee
Vanilla or Cookies & Cream
Mint chocolate chip.
Salted caramel
Pistachio
Years ago, Kemps made a French silk pie. It was the best!
Maple Bacon-brittle, followed by roasted white chocolate, and then secret breakfast (cornflake cookies and bourbon)
Orange Vanilla
Rocky road
Peanut butter chocolate
Black licorice
Strawberry
Cake batter with rainbow sprinkles!!!!
Chocolate, orange and coconut. A divine trinity.
A rich chocolate or vanilla. And the real artisan stuff, not the cheap Hagen Daz or Ben Jerry’s from the store.
Pretty torn between vanilla and cotton candy.
What I like to do with vanilla is put some peanut butter in a microwavable dish and melt it runny. Pour it over the cold ice cream, and it’ll harden a bit into this really fudgy coating. I know you can buy peanut butter topping, but the texture is totally different using actual peanut butter. It’s creamier and smoother.
Birthday cake flavor
Vallina
cookies and cream
Cherry/Pistachio
Ginseng
I love peppermint ice cream. Not mint chip. Peppermint, with pieces of peppermint candy in it. Red. So good.
Affogato
Cookie dough
Cheese flavored
mojito
French Apple
Strawberry!
Chocolate is my favorite ice cream flavour.
I love mojitos, and the irony is that the pubs in my city don’t have them on their drinks menu. They don’t have the best drink ever created.
Iogurte grego com frutas vermelhas
White chocolate pomegranate and macadamia
It’s a god tier combo
Chocolate chip mint
Cookies and cream.
Rocky Road
Belgian Chocolate
Chocolate cookies and cream
My personal go-to is Cookies And Cream. Though I hold a soft spot for both Pistachio and Coconut Almond because they were my parents’ favorites.
Lemon Chiffon, which is almost impossible to find around here
In general, cookie dough.. If specifically Ben and Jerry’s, the “Tonight Dough” . I give zero fucks about Jimmy Fallon but that stuff is gooooooood
Chocolate 🍫 with chocolate chips and chocolate topping
Three Twins (no longer in business, sadly) used to have a flavor called Dad’s Cardamon. I had never knowingly tasted cardamom before so this was a very interesting flavor.
Chocolate mixed with vanilla for sure
Lemon Pie
Mint chocolate 🙂
Tiger Tail (Orange and Black Licorice)
Choc-mint. Prefer mint with chocolate ice cream rather than with actual chocolate chips.
Chocolate
Peppermint chocolate chip! Don’t listen to the haters.
Haagen-Daz coffee ice cream
Cherry Garcia
Mango sorbet