My (25F) dad (64M) has always favored my brother (29M), which has been clear in how he supports him and celebrates his successes. I could go on for days with many examples but here’s a pretty big one:
When my brother gets good news, my dad gets emotional and often teary eyed. In contrast, when I graduated University and hosted my dad abroad, he whispered to my mom that he regretted coming and he wished he stayed home because he thought the dinner was too expensive ($150 for 5 people), our bed was uncomfortable, and our fridge smelled of kimchi. That comment really stung, especially because he didn’t even say this to me directly, rather I overheard him as I was about to fall asleep (this was at night, I was on the couch in the other room as I gave my parents our double bed).
For context, my brother is lazy and only got his current job with help from my parents, while I moved out at 21, built an independent life, and never asked for financial help.
Now, as I’m working on a business with my partner, my dad said, “If you ever want to gift us a holiday or a car, don’t feel like you need to spend too much money.” He often assumes we’ll pay for him.
AITA for telling him, “You can pay for your own holiday, you’ve got a job”?
Comments
^^^^AUTOMOD Thanks for posting! READ THIS COMMENT – DO NOT SKIM. This comment is a copy of your post so readers can see the original text if your post is edited or removed. This comment is NOT accusing you of copying anything. Read this before contacting the mod team.
My (25F) dad (64M) has always favored my brother (29M), which has been clear in how he supports him and celebrates his successes. I could go on for days with many examples but here’s a pretty big one:
When my brother gets good news, my dad gets emotional and often teary eyed. In contrast, when I graduated University and hosted my dad abroad, he whispered to my mom that he regretted coming and he wished he stayed home because he thought the dinner was too expensive ($150 for 5 people), our bed was uncomfortable, and our fridge smelled of kimchi. That comment really stung, especially because he didn’t even say this to me directly, rather I overheard him as I was about to fall asleep (this was at night, I was on the couch in the other room as I gave my parents our double bed).
For context, my brother is lazy and only got his current job with help from my parents, while I moved out at 21, built an independent life, and never asked for financial help.
Now, as I’m working on a business with my partner, my dad said, “If you ever want to gift us a holiday, don’t spend too much money.” He often assumes we’ll pay for him.
AITA for telling him, “You can pay for your own holiday, you’ve got a job”?
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
Welcome to /r/AmITheAsshole. Please view our voting guide here, and remember to use only one judgement in your comment.
OP has offered the following explanation for why they think they might be the asshole:
> 1) AITA for telling him he can pay for himself? 2) might make me an asshole as he might think that I’m being stingy or not generous, considering I’m still his daughter.
Help keep the sub engaging!
Don’t downvote assholes!
Do upvote interesting posts!
Click Here For Our Rules and Click Here For Our FAQ
Subreddit Announcements
Follow the link above to learn more
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
Contest mode is 1.5 hours long on this post.
NTA
No you are not the asshole as far as I can tell that your father is quite like a cheapskate and is more admiring of your brother.
NTA
If he has a job, you’re right! He can absolutely afford to pay his own way.
NTA. Your dad is an asshole.
I’m just curious as to where you can feed 5 people for $150. NTA.
NTA
Your golden child brother can buy him a car or vacation.
NTA, but was he actually serious with the comment about you giving them a vacation or a car? What a weird thing to say
NTA, begging for a trip from the daughter he discards over kimchi? Yea, he can definitely pay for his own holiday or get the lazy brother to pay ahahahahahahahah
NTA
It seems a little cheeky, but he sounds like he was being the same. So no again NtA
It hurtful when you’re trying so hard to give and a person complains either to
Your fave or behind your back. Some people are just like that. It’s probably better to. Or go
Out of your way for them.
I do wonder if your dad’s pride is in the way a little. What you said may actually have been a nice thing. Why would I pay for you, you do just fine.
As the child of a narcissistic and bullying father who counted every penny, I totally understand.
You owe your father nothing. Expecting you to pay for his vacations is absolutely outrageous.
NTA obviously.
Good for you to call him out! 👏🏻
Sorry to hear that your parents don’t know how to love both you and your brother. When you earn your first million, it will be OK to tell him with a See! I did this myself. Without any nepo help. And I still won’t buy you a vacay or a car. Call your favorite son.
NTA not even close. My advice would be to sit your father down and lay out your issues with him. Make it clear that you have no intention to pay for any trip of his. That if he wants to visit you, he can pay for it himself but that you don’t expect him to visit because he will “regret being there” or “complain about it every step of the way.” If you want a relationship with him, then give him a chance to correct the issues you raise with him. If he refuses, just simply go LC. That is what I did with my dad. I still see him when my sisters invite him to holidays or birthday but we don’t exchange calls or messages. He knows not to ask me for anything because for 15 years, the only time he would contact me is to get something from me or have me cover for him on something. Never cared to ask me how I’m doing or what’s going on in my life.
Essentially, you are NTA and you need to create boundaries and enforce them. People in the family will try and use emotions to manipulate you to allow him to keep treating your poorly compared to your brother. Stand your ground and maintain your boundaries. It will get better. I decided I needed therapy at the time I made the decision and it helped me stay the course and know I was doing what was best for me. I don’t need to be constantly reminded of differing treatment every time I see him. I don’t need his negativity in my life. I don’t need him destroying my happiness.
NTA – Tell him to ask his son for a holiday