Are we responsible for the disappearance of Neanderthals?

r/

Did we wipe our evolutionary brothers?

Comments

  1. AutoModerator Avatar

    📣 Reminder for our users

    >1. Check the rules: Please take a moment to review our rules, Reddiquette, and Reddit’s Content Policy.
    >2. Clear question in the title: Make sure your question is clear and placed in the title. You can add details in the body of your post, but please keep it under 600 characters.
    >3. Closed-Ended Questions Only: Questions should be closed-ended, meaning they can be answered with a clear, factual response. Avoid questions that ask for opinions instead of facts.
    >4. Be Polite and Civil: Personal attacks, harassment, or inflammatory behavior will be removed. Repeated offenses may result in a ban. Any homophobic, transphobic, racist, sexist, or bigoted remarks will result in an immediate ban.

    🚫 Commonly Asked Prohibited Question Subjects:

    >1. Medical or pharmaceutical questions
    >2. Legal or legality-related questions
    >3. Technical/meta questions (help with Reddit)

    This list is not exhaustive, so we recommend reviewing the full rules for more details on content limits.

    ✓ Mark your answers!
    >If your question has been answered, please reply with Answered!! to the response that best fit your question. This helps the community stay organized and focused on providing useful answers.


    I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

  2. its12amsomewhere Avatar

    I still see a few of them in my class

  3. Ahjumawi Avatar

    I’m not saying nothing without my attorney present.

  4. 2552686 Avatar

    Well “WE” aren’t, as it happened long before anyone on this chat were born. “WE” aren’t responsible for stuff other people, including our ancestors, do.

    Did our ancestors wipe them out? Absolutely, the Denisovians too.

  5. MrSirZeel Avatar

    Not me, I wasn’t there.

  6. Tenshiijin Avatar

    No proof to show we did. At least none that has been shared with the world.

    One thing we know for sure is there is Neanderthal DNA in many modern humans. So there was some crosbreeding of our species.

    That being said….Yes. I think we wiped them out just like we did to most of the other homonids. Thats speculative though.

  7. Hooning_over_gooning Avatar

    Damn i read the title as Netherlands and I was wondering what did I miss lol

  8. Ahshitbackagain Avatar

    Aliens wiped them out so we could flourish. Neanderthals were bigger, stronger, faster, and more brutal. No reason our weak ass homosapiens should have beat them.

    /s (sort of)

  9. Vic-Trola Avatar

    They walk amongst us.

  10. Fox_Fillory Avatar

    Yes, and I wont apologise for it, feel quite smug about it actually 😊

  11. Fartknocker9000turbo Avatar

    They were assimilated. Resistance is futile.

  12. WiseCityStepper Avatar

    if neanderthals were still around the racism towards them today would be insane, it’s for the best that we have no other top mammal on Earth

  13. KyorlSadei Avatar

    Like royal we? Because last i checked they haven’t been around for a very long time.

  14. Additional-War19 Avatar

    I first read “Netherlands” and was wondering wtf happened to Holland

  15. pvssiprincess Avatar

    Yes, we either interbred with them and some offsprings were viable and the rest we just overpowered for territory and resources. See it how you wang to.

  16. Elkyforme Avatar

    There’s plenty still around, they’re called liberals.

  17. Joseph_of_the_North Avatar

    Yeah we screwed them out of existence.

  18. GotMyOrangeCrush Avatar

    It wasn’t me, I swear.

  19. Nominay Avatar

    Death by snu snu

  20. paddydog48 Avatar

    There are still some about, currently a big sloppy one residing in the White House.

  21. ewing666 Avatar

    fuck ’em (wry smile)

  22. gadget850 Avatar

    We did the nasty in the pasty and much of their DNA is still around.

    https://humanorigins.si.edu/evidence/genetics/ancient-dna-and-neanderthals

  23. PacoSupreme Avatar

    MTG is definitely a Neanderthal or the missing link.

  24. RednoseReindog Avatar

    No we aren’t, Neanderthals had us landlocked for thousands of years.

  25. spritz_bubbles Avatar

    They’re not gone.

  26. spderweb Avatar

    We actually share DNA with them and one other hominid. Humans today are a direct result of those interspecies interactions.

    One of the first people that we really locked that in with was Ozzy Osborn. They figure his neanderthal DNA is why he’s not dead yet from all the drugs and alcohol.

  27. spaacingout Avatar

    Very possible, there’s a gap in history just proceeding the emergence of our species. Some theorize it was because early humans ate everything they could cram down their gullet, including bones, so even if giants or elves or other human-like divergent species did exist, they would’ve been gobbled up by our ancestors after tribal genocide and left no trace.

    Neanderthal was just the only remnants of a divergent hominid species that we could prove

    And we all know humanity’s capacity for hate towards those who are different.

    There could have been many variations of humans, but they would have all been eaten by our ancestors.

    It makes me wonder if human mutations are just an echo of divergence, things like giantism, dwarfism and achondroplasia. There’s your giants, dwarves and gnomes lol

    If you wanna get really wierd about evolution or mutations, some children are still born with a preaucular pit (forgive my spelling) or a tail.

    What do you think about human “gills” and tails? lol

  28. False_Ad3429 Avatar

    We absorbed them into our population

  29. knuckboy Avatar

    What do you mean we? I wasn’t around and didn’t ever know anyone who was.

  30. leo-sapiens Avatar

    I read somewhere that no. Maybe partially, by taking over some of the food sources and adapting better, but we didn’t kill them off directly. They were just less well adapted to changing environments. But some mixed with us.

  31. Mushrooming247 Avatar

    From the timeline, it does seem like we wiped them out at the same time our species were interbreeding, and it makes sense to me, knowing humans.

    Think of how tribal we are, how much some humans can’t tolerate people who look different.

    Without laws against murder and the threat of prison, I believe 1/3 of the US would proudly attack and murder any population that was too different from themselves, as that is the basis of their political opinions and is often central to their personality.

  32. throwaway007676 Avatar

    I honestly believe they are still here, it is easy to tell. Many of them even wear red hats to identify themselves.

  33. Wolfman01a Avatar

    Small town Midwesterner here. There’s still plenty of them left. I see them nearly everywhere I go.

  34. Anthroman78 Avatar

    You caught me, I did it. Didn’t mean to do it, sometimes shit happens.

  35. KnoWanUKnow2 Avatar

    Probably. Through a mix of competition for resources, interbreeding, and even direct warfare.

    But don’t feel too bad. We also are responsible for the extinction of the Denisovans and several other hominid species.

  36. Communal-Lipstick Avatar

    Not all of us, just you.

  37. The_Itsy_BitsySpider Avatar

    Humans have a literal fear of things that look human but feel a little off, we call it “uncanny valley” and its more then likely that its a adaptation that is remnant of our initial interactions not just with Neanderthals, but any other kind of proto human that was developing in the hundreds of thousands of years before we built civilizations. We needed to be able to quickly identify and be warry of things that appeared human, but were just slightly off, which with Neanderthal’s slightly different skull shape effecting the facial proportions, and a skeleton with slightly elongated limb proportions compared to normal humans, that seems to be the biggest influencer of that uncanny valley feel.

    We did breed with them, their dna is in a portion of the human population, but we certainly after a while either assimilated them all through breeding, or butchered them when our numbers became large enough.

    Almost every major predator that existed along side us is believed to have been snuffed out by us. Lions are a great example, once the most widely spread super predator on land, then humans showed up and they were driven to the small populations we see now.

  38. ThePensiveE Avatar

    We’ll be responsible for the disappearance of Homo Sapiens too.

  39. Boundary-Interface Avatar

    Yes, we as humans did drive neanderthals to extinction, and we’re not sad or sorry about it.

  40. Indigo-Waterfall Avatar

    Yes kind of. But also We ARE Neanderthals… we share part of our dna showing some cross breeding happened relatively often.

  41. WNCsurvivor Avatar

    No they’re all in Washington DC

  42. darkestvice Avatar

    We bred with their hottest, and wiped out the rest, yup.

  43. LosPer Avatar

    Oh shit. Do we have to do Neanderthal DNA acknowledgments now, too?

    opens Google Doc to edit speech and types furiously

    “We humbly acknowledge that we exist today on the genetic remnants of those who came before us—specifically, the Neanderthals, who graciously allowed Homo sapiens to outbreed, outfight, and ultimately outlast them, often without so much as a thank-you note.

    We recognize that, while only 1–2% of their DNA remains in most of us, their legacy lives on—in our love of meat, occasional unibrows, and irrational fear of change.

    To the Neanderthals: we apologize for ghosting you approximately 40,000 years ago, after what was clearly a complicated interspecies situationship. You deserved better.

    May we never forget the strong brows and stronger forearms of those who fell so we could scroll endlessly.”

  44. yeahyoubetnot Avatar

    Only partially.

  45. NoxAstrumis1 Avatar

    Nobody knows. All we can say is that we did interbreed with them, and they disappeared. Perhaps we both integrated with them and killed them off.

    There is a theory that their adaptations weren’t as well suited to European living, so we just out-competed them.

  46. DingoFlamingoThing Avatar

    They were mostly “integrated” into homo sapien society…..consensually.

  47. Moesko_Island Avatar

    Partially, but we also kind of absorbed them, too.

  48. ZaphodG Avatar

    They didn’t disappear. They’re congressmen.

  49. Skitteringscamper Avatar

    Technically yes. They bred, but DNA was recessive. 

    So over time they just, bred themselves into being us. Like how ginger genetics are recessive so you need both to be ginger, blond or black will always override the ginger genetics otherwise. 

    Certain races round the world do have higher percentages of neanderthal DNA in them, probs where higher concentrations of them lived in the past. 

    Also we came close to extinction a few times so probs ended up living together for safety. Homo and homo all huddling together against the terrors of their world and the environment trying to kill them too at that point in time.

    But it’s very unlikely we actively hunted them like some conspiracy theory suggests. Who basically took the werewolves from that dark fantasy and replaced them with Neanderthals hunting us down instead. 

  50. waynaferd Avatar

    I think they just evolved into what most of us are today. Although some of us have not evolved enough lol

  51. Grittybroncher88 Avatar

    You clearly haven’t been to Florida.