I (20F) feel horrible after my boyfriend (21M) dismissed the gifts I planned for him before going long distance

r/

My boyfriend and I are going long distance in a few days, and I had planned a set of gifts for him. Here’s what I prepared:

  1. A diary (I filled it with kisses and a few notes)
  2. Orchids (his favorite flowers)
  3. Matching keychains
  4. A nail cutter (he bites his nails a lot, and I thought maybe giving him one would motivate him to grow them out)
  5. A T-shirt (i could not think of anything to gift a guy cause I’ve never done that before. since he was gonna shop for himself before his flight, i thought why not contribute something useful)
  6. A paper bouquet (made with purple paper cause he loves purple a lot)
  7. Letters “A piece of me” (something sentimental and personal)

    The issue is, yesterday I went shopping with one of my guy friends. My boyfriend was aware that I was out with him. In fact it was him who dropped me to the place. I was actually shopping for my boyfriend, but of course I couldn’t tell him that at the time, and my friend also needed to shop for himself.

    In the middle of shopping, my boyfriend called and asked if I wanted to go somewhere with him. I told him I couldn’t, since I needed to stay. I could sense that he felt bad, so I texted him to explain that I was actually out shopping for him. He said he felt “cheated” because of the way i said i needed to be there.

I asked him to come pick me up, and he did. We talked, but I was already feeling guilty until he pulled up a Reddit post and made me read a comment that said something like: “Don’t gift your boyfriend things you like or want him to gift yo- no handwritten notes or anything sentimental.” I didn’t like it at all. I don’t even know what message he was trying to convey, but it hurt deeply.

I’ve already prepared the diary and the bouquet, and now I don’t even feel like giving them to him anymore. I ended up showing him my chats with friends (including the guy I was shopping with) as proof of what I had been planning. I even had to show him the exact list of gifts. After we finished talking about it , he said: “I can’t believe you thought a T-shirt was a good gift.” i don’t know if he said that as a joke or actually meant it.

Now I feel discouraged because I think he’s one of those guys who do not value such efforts. Don’t get me wrong, he loves me. He’s financially well-off and can buy himself anything he wants. That’s part of why I thought meaningful, handmade, and sentimental gifts would matter more. Instead, I just feel horrible.

Later, he told me he doesn’t like surprises and asked why we couldn’t have gone shopping for the gifts together. Long ago, we had a conversation where he said he believes gifts should be something practical and useful, something the receiver wouldn’t normally buy for themselves. I kept that in mind when I planned everything.

Right now, I just feel defeated and even a little bit like I hate myself for trying so hard.

My question is: am I overreacting? Should I still give him the gifts I prepared, or just let it go?

TL;DR: I spent weeks planning thoughtful and sentimental gifts for my boyfriend before we go long distance. He criticized my idea, and now I feel unappreciated and unsure if I should even give them.

Comments

  1. Existing_Tutor7616 Avatar

    This is coming from a very sensitive person, so take that with a grain of salt while reading this comment. I don’t think you’re overreacting at all. You were showing your love. You were going out of your way to be vulnerable and making another/many tiny forms of making connections. You spent your time, money, and energy on it in hopes to make him happy. Not for him to thank you or praise you, but to make him happy. I don’t know if you are, but I’m a swiftie. Taylor has a song called tolerate it, where the lyrics are, “I wait by the door like I’m just a kid. Use my best colors for your portrait. Lay the table with the fancy s*!t, and watch you tolerate it” but in this case, your boyfriend isn’t even tolerating it, he’s rejecting it and breaking you/it down. And I feel like a person shouldn’t react that way. He should’ve treated you the way he’d want to be treated. It wouldn’t have killed him to say “thank you, that was sweet.” You are not overreacting and you have every right to feel the way that you do

  2. RollingKatamari Avatar

    I think this guy wants to break up with you. Dude had a freaking Reddit post to back him up! He had a Reddit post doing the talking for him, all to say that he thinks you messed up.

    You seem entirely incompatible!
    OP, you deserve someone who will appreciate the thought you put in these lovely gifts. You have this love inside of you to give, this creativity and sweetness…and he wants NOTHING to do with it!

    Listen, you two are very young and long distance relationships are hard.

    I think it’s probably best for the both of you to let each other go and let each other live your lives without the pressure of being in a relationship.

  3. GeekyPassion Avatar

    Find someone that appreciates you