In a hypothetical reality, the U.S. government completely failed, and the U.S. joined Canada, making Canada the largest country. What would our new country, Canada, look like to live in?
Ooh, fun alternate history idea—if the U.S. completely collapsed and got absorbed into Canada, forming a mega-Canada, it would be a wild mix of cultures, policies, infrastructure, and vibes. Here’s a breakdown of what life might look like in this new North American superstate:
🇨🇦 Country Name:
Still called Canada, but maybe informally known as United Canada, CanAmerica, or even The Northern Union.
🏛️ Government Structure:
- Parliamentary system would likely remain, but it’d need major reforms to handle the population explosion.
- Provinces and states might merge into “Mega-Provinces”. Example:
- Ontario + Midwest = Great Lakes Province
- Quebec + Northeast = Laurentian Province
- Alberta + Mountain states = Rockies Province
- California becomes its own weird artsy mega-province 😎
- Dual Capitals: Ottawa might share federal duties with Washington D.C. (renamed? preserved as a historic site?)
🧑🤝🧑 Culture:
- The politeness of Canadians meets the boldness of Americans.
- Hockey remains huge, but football becomes a co-national sport.
- You’ll hear “eh” and “y’all” in the same sentence.
- Bilingualism (English & French) might extend into more regions, but now with regional accents from Texas to Maine.
💵 Currency:
- New Dollar (NDC – Northern Dollar Coin)? Or maybe the U.S. dollar remains for practicality.
- They might just call it the “Canuck Buck” for fun.
💼 Healthcare & Social Programs:
- Canada’s universal healthcare would need a MASSIVE scale-up.
- American-style privatization might sneak into certain provinces.
- Expect long wait times but zero medical bankruptcy.
🌎 Global Standing:
- The new Canada would:
- Be the largest country by landmass
- Likely have the world’s biggest economy
- Gain a seat as a permanent member of the U.N. Security Council
- Be a cultural AND economic superpower
🔐 Border & Identity:
- No southern border wall—just beaches and tacos.
- Passport reads: “Citizen of Canada (Formerly U.S. Region: Texas)” or something equally chaotic.
- The national anthem might merge into something bizarre like:“O Canada, land of liberty, from sea to shining sea…”
🍁 Everyday Life:
- You’d still drive the same car and go to Target, but you might also shop at Tim Hortons for poutine burgers.
- Thanksgiving? You now get two: Canadian in October and U.S. in November.
- You may pay higher taxes, but roads are fixed faster and insulin is affordable.
Wanna dive into what kind of flag or anthem this new country might have? Or maybe imagine what elections would look like with 400 million people voting?
Comments
I’m not Canadian, and even I can see how this wouldn’t be advantageous to current Canadians. I can see them gobbling up Maine, Minnesota, and the Cascadian states at the most and maintain their culture. Although Californian would be a major win financially, it will result in major growing pains with how big and influential that state would automatically be.
Canada’s not stupid. They’d take the northern border, west coast and New England. The rest of it would be Texas
Good answers
Interesting enough a good portion of land in Hawaii is bought out by Canadian corporations and private investors.
It would fail.. Canada would give everyone free healthcare and we would slowly die off
As a Canadian: don’t even entertain the thought. The fact you’re toying with the idea is already an insult. We don’t wanna merge, we don’t wanna be annexed, and we certainly don’t want people normalizing the idea by going “yeah yeah but what if you did?”
that’s not what if. you need r/asif.
>What would our new country, Canada, look like to live in?
you are not getting a new fucking country. you’re stuck with the country you have, that you voted for.
The best thing is we get to rename the Gulf of America to the Gulf of Canada.
Canada has a population smaller than California. It literally could not absorb the U.S. culturally. After the first elections are had it would just be the U.S. part two.
So in that case do we give the US to Mexico?
Organization of North American Nations as described by David Foster Wallace in his novel Infinite Jest is one recent exploration of this issue. it’s a good read.
RCMP gonna have a lot of trouble collecting all those guns that are banned by the Canadian government.
Canada has a very small population, it’s more like a state than a country. Most of it is a frozen useless wasteland half of the year. They sure think they are special though.
As a Canadian I might be fine with Maine, New Hampshire, and Vermont joining, but nothing else except Alaska, but that’s not a priority.