R1 postdoc vs. 3/3 tenure track

r/

Hi all, I am a humanities PhD at an R1 institution and this job cycle I’m lucky to have received two offers that I’m considering, but I’m finding it difficult to make a decision, especially when academia is even more precarious than usual. The first is an offer for a Assistant Professor position at an undergrad serving institution. This is a teaching-focused school with not much research support in a small town in the midwest. The second job is a postdoc for up to 3 years at an R1, with a lower salary but also much lower teaching load and in a city I’d like to live in. My worry is that if I take the TT job, with the teaching and service responsibilities, it will be very difficult to keep up a competitive profile to transition to a research university or SLAC. Taking the postdoc I would happier in the short term with more time to write, but then complete uncertainty. Any insight into how either of these options would play on the job market in the future?