Would you consider Theodore Roosevelt a Liberal?

r/

  1. Trust-Busting

Broke up monopolies and large corporate trusts (e.g., Northern Securities Company) under the Sherman Antitrust Act.

Sought to ensure fair competition and reduce corporate power over markets.

  1. Regulation of Corporations

Created the Bureau of Corporations to investigate business practices.

Strengthened the Interstate Commerce Commission (ICC) to regulate railroad rates with the Hepburn Act (1906).

  1. Consumer Protection

Championed the Pure Food and Drug Act and Meat Inspection Act (1906), expanding federal power to regulate food and medicine industries.

  1. Labor Advocacy

Intervened in the 1902 Coal Strike not to crush the unions, but to mediate between labor and management—a novel approach at the time.

Supported the right of workers to organize and called for improved labor conditions.

  1. Environmental Conservation

Established 5 national parks, 18 national monuments, and over 150 national forests.

Created the United States Forest Service and greatly expanded federal land protection.

  1. Progressive Reforms

Advocated for progressive taxation, such as a graduated income tax (later realized in the 16th Amendment).

Supported inheritance taxes on the wealthy.

Urged campaign finance reform to reduce corporate influence on elections.

  1. Social Justice and Equity

Called for a “Square Deal”, promoting fair treatment for workers, consumers, and businesses alike.

Although not fully aligned with civil rights for African Americans, he did invite Booker T. Washington to the White House—symbolic for its time.

  1. Government Oversight and Intervention

Believed the federal government should regulate the economy in the public interest.

Supported state and federal regulation over laissez-faire capitalism.

  1. Public Health and Safety

Supported increased government responsibility for urban sanitation, public health campaigns, and infrastructure safety.

Comments

  1. AutoModerator Avatar

    The following is a copy of the original post to record the post as it was originally written.

    1. Trust-Busting

    Broke up monopolies and large corporate trusts (e.g., Northern Securities Company) under the Sherman Antitrust Act.

    Sought to ensure fair competition and reduce corporate power over markets.

    1. Regulation of Corporations

    Created the Bureau of Corporations to investigate business practices.

    Strengthened the Interstate Commerce Commission (ICC) to regulate railroad rates with the Hepburn Act (1906).

    1. Consumer Protection

    Championed the Pure Food and Drug Act and Meat Inspection Act (1906), expanding federal power to regulate food and medicine industries.

    1. Labor Advocacy

    Intervened in the 1902 Coal Strike not to crush the unions, but to mediate between labor and management—a novel approach at the time.

    Supported the right of workers to organize and called for improved labor conditions.

    1. Environmental Conservation

    Established 5 national parks, 18 national monuments, and over 150 national forests.

    Created the United States Forest Service and greatly expanded federal land protection.

    1. Progressive Reforms

    Advocated for progressive taxation, such as a graduated income tax (later realized in the 16th Amendment).

    Supported inheritance taxes on the wealthy.

    Urged campaign finance reform to reduce corporate influence on elections.

    1. Social Justice and Equity

    Called for a “Square Deal”, promoting fair treatment for workers, consumers, and businesses alike.

    Although not fully aligned with civil rights for African Americans, he did invite Booker T. Washington to the White House—symbolic for its time.

    1. Government Oversight and Intervention

    Believed the federal government should regulate the economy in the public interest.

    Supported state and federal regulation over laissez-faire capitalism.

    1. Public Health and Safety

    Supported increased government responsibility for urban sanitation, public health campaigns, and infrastructure safety.

    I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

  2. Odd-Principle8147 Avatar

    He was actually a progressive liberal. The real name of the Bull Moose part was the Progressive Party.

  3. srv340mike Avatar

    Yes, 100%, especially relative to his time, but he even holds up now with the label I think.

  4. ButGravityAlwaysWins Avatar

    For the standard of the time he would be a liberal on the further left of the party. You could call him at progressive. Actually his party name was the progressive party.

    For the standard of any time he would be a bad ass and an excellent leader

  5. MasterCrumb Avatar

    Really the biggest break is around imperialism, which until very recently wasn’t a liberal/conservative dividing issue. He was a clear imperialist and was in favor of military expansionism. Definitely would be excited about taking Greenland.

  6. Okratas Avatar

    Theodore Roosevelt sought to maintain and implement conservative liberal policies within the framework of the progressive wing of the Republican Party. He’s what today is known as progressive conservatism.

  7. ReadinII Avatar

    In terms of modern ideology, he was very much a big government liberal on much domestic economic and environmental policy. 

    His “speak softly and carry a big stick” fits more with traditional (pre-Trump) modern conservativism. 

    His belief that immigrants should become and be accepted as just American (as opposed to being perpetual “hyphenated Americans”) is very traditional (pre-Trump) modern conservative as well. 

  8. TheLastCoagulant Avatar

    Written by ChatGPT.

  9. Pls_no_steal Avatar

    It’s hard to label people centuries ago with modern ideologies. He was progressive for his time but many of his views would be seen as reprehensible now, especially his opinions on foreign policy

  10. Brilliant-Book-503 Avatar

    I think the Liberal/Conservative divide is a tough thing to apply to other times in history or other countries.

    Nixon and George W also did a lot for national parks.

    Regan, the patron saint of conservatism spoke about undocumented immigrants and policy towards them that would get anyone branded a “libtard” today.

    After Roe v. Wade passed, many democrats, including Joe Biden were against the ruling and some prominent republicans were big supporters.

    Clinton through both terms and Obama in his first had policies and expressed viewpoints on LGBTQ people that would get anyone labelled a homophobic bigot to express today.

    And until MAGA, even the conservatives hadn’t fully bought into “starve the beast”. Plenty of Republicans in the not too distant past were on board with some basic empathy and belief the government could do things and that’s not a bad thing.

    It’s all very relative.

    I think the labels are less useful the farther you get from the present context. But if you really wanted to try to apply them, you’d want to look at the national dialogue in the moment and compare them to social norms and their opposition. Someone MORE on the side of protecting underserved groups, MORE of the belief that government can and should do things that markets fail at etc could probably be seen as aligned with liberal ideas,

  11. almondjuice442 Avatar

    He’s further left than most liberals, I’d call him a progressive

  12. SirVipe5 Avatar

    The OG Bull Moose Progressive

  13. zombiepoppper Avatar

    He wouldn’t be a Republican I’ll tell you that. They’d call him woke if he tried defending Alaska from oil drilling. 

  14. AstroBullivant Avatar

    “Thank God I’m not a Free Trader” — Theodore Roosevelt

    He definitely supported some degree of Protectionism in trade.

  15. Kerplonk Avatar

    Yes. I think you can make some arguments against, especially if you ignore that society tends to progress over time, but by and large I would say he falls squarely under the liberal label.

  16. Apprehensive-Fruit-1 Avatar

    Honestly, the Roosevelt family needs a comeback. With Teddy and FDR, they shaped this country for the better. Just ignore all the racist shit